Comparison · 2026

Comparison
SiftlyvsSemrush

Siftly vs Semrush AI Visibility

Both measure AI visibility. Only Siftly also does the work to fix it.

Siftly and the Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit both track how AI describes your brand across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Overviews. The difference is what comes next: Semrush stops at the gaps; Siftly also closes them — content, citations and feeds — and ties it to revenue.
Track it. Fix it. Win it.
Written by Chalam PVS, Founder, Siftly · Last updated 16 June 2026

At a glance

Feature

Type

Siftly

Semrush AI Visibility

AI add-on to an SEO suite

Visibility, share of voice, sentiment

Siftly

Yes

Semrush AI Visibility

Yes

AI engines tracked

Siftly

9 (incl. Claude, Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek)

Semrush AI Visibility

~3–4 — ChatGPT, AI Overviews, AI Mode; no Claude/Copilot/Grok/DeepSeek

Refresh · prompts · language

Siftly

Daily · your real prompts · multi-geo

Semrush AI Visibility

Weekly · synthetic prompts · US-English

Competitor benchmarking

Siftly

Yes

Semrush AI Visibility

Yes (up to 4)

Prompt research

Siftly

Yes

Semrush AI Visibility

Yes

Creates content AI cites

Siftly

Yes — done-for-you + publish

Semrush AI Visibility

No

Social & community execution (Reddit, LinkedIn, YouTube)

Siftly

Yes

Semrush AI Visibility

No — surfaces threads only

Citation outreach

Siftly

Yes — finds author + runs email sequences

Semrush AI Visibility

Partial — finds targets & drafts pitches; you run it

AI shopping / product feeds

Siftly

Yes

Semrush AI Visibility

No

Traditional SEO suite (backlinks, Google KW)

Siftly

No

Semrush AI Visibility

Yes

Entry price

Siftly

Free, then $79/mo

Semrush AI Visibility

$99/mo per domain

Best for

Siftly

Winning AI search end-to-end

Semrush AI Visibility

SEO teams adding AI tracking

How we compared: hands-on testing plus Semrush's public docs/KB, independent reviews and pricing as of June 2026. Pricing and AI-engine coverage change fast — verify before relying on them.

Scorecard

Five buyer-weighted dimensions
SiftlySemrush
Visibility tracking
9
7
Execution (content, citations, feeds)
9
2
AI shopping / product feeds
8
1
Traditional SEO breadth
2
10
Ease of starting / price
9
6
How Siftly and Semrush AI Visibility score across the five dimensions buyers weigh most (Siftly internal assessment, June 2026).

The core difference: tracking vs execution

Measurement

Semrush AI Visibility is a capable tracker — it reports your share of voice, sentiment, and which prompts you win or lose. But tracking is the easy, commoditized half, and Siftly does all of it too. The hard part is what comes after — and that's where Semrush stops: by its own documentation and independent reviews, it only identifies opportunities; acting on them is left to you. You still write the content, add the schema, and chase the third-party mentions yourself. Siftly closes that loop for you.

Visibility by Platform chart showing AI visibility across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AIO.
Execution

Siftly closes that loop. It tracks the same signals, then does the work: it reverse-engineers what AI cites and publishes ready-to-rank content to your CMS, drafts value-first Reddit and social engagement, runs citation outreach on your behalf, and optimizes product feeds for AI shopping — then follows the impact from crawl to citation to click to revenue.

Published Content table showing AI visibility articles, prompts, citations, and update dates.

Where they differ, by criterion

Execution✓ Winner: Siftly
Siftly
Closes the gaps in-platform — publishes content, runs value-first Reddit (80/20, multi-profile), LinkedIn & YouTube, automated citation-outreach sequences, and product feeds. Often done-for-you.
Semrush
Hands you a prioritized gap list and drafts outreach pitches — you do the work.
Bottom line: with a content + technical team, Semrush's list is enough. Without one, Siftly is the difference between insight and outcome.
Coverage⇄ It depends
Siftly
Tracks 9 engines, daily, multi-geo; two-sided — Answers (B2B) + Shopping (products, incl. feeds Semrush doesn't offer).
Semrush
Tracks ~3–4 engines, weekly (no Claude/Copilot/Grok/DeepSeek) — but a full traditional-SEO suite.
Bottom line: Siftly tracks more of AI search, more often; Semrush is wider in classic SEO.
$ Pricing & value✓ Winner: Siftly (entry)
Siftly
Free, then $79/mo.
Semrush
$99/mo per domain · ~$239/mo with SEO separately · Semrush One from ~$165/mo by tier.
Bottom line: Semrush's price buys tracking; Siftly's buys tracking plus execution. Full Siftly pricing →

Pros and cons

Siftly

Pros
  • End-to-end execution — content, citations, feeds
  • Two-sided: answers + shopping
  • Free tier; revenue attribution
Cons
  • Not a full traditional-SEO suite (no backlink / Google-keyword tools)

Semrush AI Visibility

Pros
  • 260M+ prompt database
  • Lives inside a mature SEO suite
  • Enterprise-proven data
Cons
  • Tracking only — no content, citation or feed execution
  • Tracks only ~3–4 engines (no Claude/Copilot/Grok/DeepSeek), weekly, US-English
  • Identifies outreach targets + drafts pitches, but you do the work
  • Add-on that gets pricey with extras

Who should choose which

Choose Semrush if…

  • You have a team to execute on what it finds.
  • You want measurement and prompt discovery in one suite.

Choose Siftly if…

  • You want the work done, not just measured.
  • You sell products and need AI-shopping and feed optimization.
  • You want a free start and revenue attribution.

Can you use both?

✓ Yes — many teams do
Run both: keep Semrush for traditional Google SEO and prompt research; use Siftly as the execution layer that turns AI-search insights into published content, earned citations and optimized feeds.
1
Pick one (AI search first): Siftly covers tracking too — so you're not paying twice to measure.
3.5×
revenue from ChatGPT, month over month
“Siftly helped us grow revenue from ChatGPT by 3.5× month over month. It showed us AI search is a real, measurable revenue channel — and the on-brand content keeps us showing up across ChatGPT and Google AI Mode.”— Emi, KIWABI (Japan)

The bottom line

Want one suite for SEO + AI tracking?
Semrush is a sound choice — if you have the team to act on what it finds.
Want to win AI search end-to-end?
Siftly gets you cited, recommended and chosen, with content and outreach done for you — and covers tracking too.
Measurement tells you the score; execution changes it.

Frequently asked questions

No. The AI Visibility Toolkit is a tracking and discovery tool — it surfaces gaps, and you act on them. Siftly creates the content and executes the work.
Siftly starts free, then $79/mo. The Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit is $99/mo per domain; with SEO it runs about $239/mo separately, or is bundled in Semrush One from roughly $165/mo by tier, plus per-prompt and per-seat add-ons.
Yes — Siftly Shopping optimizes product pages and Shopify and Merchant Center feeds for AI shopping surfaces; Semrush has no shopping-feed execution.
For AI search specifically, yes — Siftly is a Semrush alternative built for execution, not just tracking. For broad traditional SEO, Semrush is still the wider suite, so many teams use them together.
Both track your visibility. Semrush stops at measurement; Siftly also executes — content, Reddit and social, citation outreach, and product feeds — and ties it to revenue.
For AI search, yes — Siftly tracks and executes. For broad traditional SEO like backlinks and Google keyword research, Semrush is a wider suite, so some teams keep both.
ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, with Gemini and Perplexity rolling out (as of June 2026). It does not track Claude, Copilot, Grok or DeepSeek, refreshes weekly, and covers US-English only. Siftly tracks all nine engines, daily, across geographies.

See where you stand in AI search — free.

No sign-up. Get your AI visibility and the gaps to fix in 30 seconds.